Category Archives: Event Report

Introduction

The last plenary meeting of the Video Quality Experts Group (VQEG) was held online by the University of Konstantz (Germany) in December 18th to 21st, 2023. It offered the possibility to more than 100 registered participants from 19 different countries worldwide to attend the numerous presentations and discussions about topics related to the ongoing projects within VQEG. All the related information, minutes, and files from the meeting are available online in the VQEG meeting website, and video recordings of the meeting are soon available at Youtube.

All the topics mentioned below can be of interest for the SIGMM community working on quality assessment, but special attention can be devoted to the current activities on improvements of the statistical analysis of subjective experiments and objective metrics and on the development of a test plan to evaluate the QoE of immersive interactive communication systems in collaboration with ITU.

Readers of these columns interested in the ongoing projects of VQEG are encouraged to suscribe to the VQEG’s  email reflectors to follow the activities going on and to get involved with them.

As already announced in the VQEG website, the next VQEG plenary meeting be hosted by Universität Klagenfurt in Austria from July 1^st to 5th, 2024.

Overview of VQEG Projects

Audiovisual HD (AVHD)

The AVHD group works on developing and validating subjective and objective methods to analyze commonly available video systems. During the meeting, there were various sessions in which presentations related to these topics were discussed.

Firstly, Ali Ak (Nantes Université, France), provided an analysis of the relation between acceptance/annoyance and visual quality in a recently collected dataset of several User Generated Content (UGC) videos. Then, Syed Uddin (AGH University of Krakow, Poland) presented a video quality assessment method based on the quantization parameter of MPEG encoders (MPEG-4, MPEG-AVC, and MPEG-HEVC) leveraging VMAF. In addition, Sang Heon Le (LG Electronics, Korea) presented a technique for pre-enhancement for video compression and applicable subjective quality metrics. Another talk was given by Alexander Raake (TU Ilmenau, Germany), who presented AVQBits, a versatile no-reference bitstream-based video quality model (based on the standardized ITU-T P.1204.3 model) that can be applied in several contexts such as video service monitoring, evaluation of video encoding quality, of gaming video QoE, and even of omnidirectional video quality. Also, Jingwen Zhu (Nantes Université, France) and Hadi Amirpour (University of Klagenfurt, Austria) described a study on the evaluation of the effectiveness of different video quality metrics in predicting the Satisfied User Ratio (SUR) in order to enhance the VMAF proxy to better capture content-specific characteristics. Andreas Pastor (Nantes Université, France) presented a method to predict the distortion perceived locally by human eyes in AV1-encoded videos using deep features, which can be easily integrated into video codecs as a pre-processing step before starting encoding.

In relation with standardization efforts, Mathias Wien (RWTH Aachen University, Germany) gave an overview on recent expert viewing tests that have been conducted within MPEG AG5 at the 143rd and 144th MPEG meetings. Also, Kamil Koniuch (AGH University of Krakow, Poland) presented a proposal to update the Survival Game task defined in the ITU-T Recommendation P.1301 on subjective quality evaluation of audio and audiovisual multiparty telemeetings, in order to improve its implementation and application to recent efforts such as the evaluation of immersive communication systems within the ITU-T P.IXC (see the paragraph related to the Immersive Media Group).

Quality Assessment for Health applications (QAH)

The QAH group is focused on the quality assessment of health applications. It addresses subjective evaluation, generation of datasets, development of objective metrics, and task-based approaches. Recently, the group has been working towards an ITU-T recommendation for the assessment of medical contents. On this topic, Meriem Outtas (INSA Rennes, France) led a discussion dealing with the edition of a draft of this recommendation. In addition, Lumi Xia (INSA Rennes, France) presented a study of task-based medical image quality assessment focusing on a use case of adrenal lesions.

Statistical Analysis Methods (SAM)

The group SAM investigates on analysis methods both for the results of subjective experiments and for objective quality models and metrics. This was one of the most active groups in this meeting, with several presentations on related topics.

On this topic, Krzystof Rusek (AGH University of Krakow, Poland) presented a Python package to estimate Generalized Score Distribution (GSD) parameters and showed how to use it to test the results obtained in subjective experiments. Andreas Pastor (Nantes Université, France) presented a comparison between two subjective studies using Absolute Category Rating with Hidden Reference (ACR-HR) and Degradation Category Rating (DCR), conducted in a controlled laboratory environment on SDR HD, UHD, and HDR UHD contents using naive observers. The goal of these tests is to estimate rate-distortion savings between two modern video codecs and compare the precision and accuracy of both subjective methods. He also presented another study on the comparison of conditions for omnidirectional video with spatial audio in terms of subjective quality and impacts on objective metrics resolving power.

In addition, Lukas Krasula (Netflix, USA) introduced e2nest, a web-based platform to conduct media-centric (video, audio, and images) subjective tests. Also, Dietmar Saupe (University of Konstanz, Germany) and Simon Del Pin (NTNU, Norway) showed the results of a study analyzing the national difference in image quality assessment, showing significant differences in various areas. Alexander Raake (TU Ilmenau, Germany) presented a study on the remote testing of high resolution images and videos, using AVrate Voyager , which is a publicly accessible framework for online tests. Finally, Dominik Keller (TU Ilmenau, Germany) presented a recent study exploring the impact of 8K (UHD-2) resolution on HDR video quality, considering different viewing distances. The results showed that the enhanced video quality of 8K HDR over 4K HDR diminishes with increasing viewing distance.

No Reference Metrics (NORM)

The group NORM addresses a collaborative effort to develop no-reference metrics for monitoring visual service quality. In At this meeting, Ioannis Katsavounidis (Meta, USA) led a discussion on the current efforts to improve complexity image and video metrics. In addition, Krishna Srikar Durbha (Univeristy of Texas at Austin, USA) presented a technique to tackle the problem of bitrate ladder construction based on multiple Visual Information Fidelity (VIF) feature sets extracted from different scales and subbands of a video

Emerging Technologies Group (ETG)

The ETG group focuses on various aspects of multimedia that, although they are not necessarily directly related to “video quality”, can indirectly impact the work carried out within VQEG and are not addressed by any of the existing VQEG groups. In particular, this group aims to provide a common platform for people to gather together and discuss new emerging topics, possible collaborations in the form of joint survey papers, funding proposals, etc.

In this meeting, Nabajeet Barman and Saman Zadtootaghaj (Sony Interactive Entertainment, Germany), suggested a topic to start to be discussed within VQEG: Quality Assessment of AI Generated/Modified Content. The goal is to have subsequent discussions on this topic within the group and write a position or whitepaper.

Joint Effort Group (JEG) – Hybrid

The group JEG addresses several areas of Video Quality Assessment (VQA), such as the creation of a large dataset for training such models using full-reference metrics instead of subjective metrics. In addition, the group includes the VQEG project Implementer’s Guide for Video Quality Metrics (IGVQM). At the meeting, Enrico Masala (Politecnico di Torino, Italy) provided  updates on the activities of the group and on IGVQM.

Apart from this, there were three presentations addressing related topics in this meeting, delivered by Lohic Fotio Tiotsop (Politecnico di Torino, Italy). The first presentation focused on quality estimation in subjective experiments and the identification of peculiar subject behaviors, introducing a robust approach for estimating subjective quality from noisy ratings, and a novel subject scoring model that enables highlighting several peculiar behaviors. Also, he introduced a non-parametric perspective to address the media quality recovery problem, without making any a priori assumption on the subjects’ scoring behavior. Finally, he presented an approach called “human-in-the-loop training process” that uses  multiple cycles of a human voting, DNN training, and inference procedure.

Immersive Media Group (IMG)

The IMG group is performing research on the quality assessment of immersive media technologies. Currently, the main joint activity of the group is the development of a test plan to evaluate the QoE of immersive interactive communication systems, which is carried out in collaboration with ITU-T through the work item P.IXC. In this meeting, Pablo Pérez (Nokia XR Lab, Spain), Jesús Gutiérrez (Universidad Politécnica de Madrid, Spain), Kamil Koniuch (AGH University of Krakow, Poland), Ashutosh Singla (CWI, The Netherlands) and other researchers involved in the test plan provided an update on the status of the test plan, focusing on the description of four interactive tasks to be performed in the test, the considered measures, and the 13 different experiments that will be carried out in the labs involved in the test plan. Also, in relation with this test plan, Felix Immohr (TU Ilmenau, Germany), presented a study on the impact of spatial audio on social presence and user behavior in multi-modal VR communications.

Quality Assessment for Computer Vision Applications (QACoViA)

The group QACoViA addresses the study the visual quality requirements for computer vision methods, where the final user is an algorithm. In this meeting, Mikołaj Leszczuk (AGH University of Krakow, Poland) and  Jingwen Zhu (Nantes Université, France) presented a specialized data set developed for enhancing Automatic License Plate Recognition (ALPR) systems. In addition, Hanene Brachemi (IETR-INSA Rennes, France), presented an study on evaluating the vulnerability of deep learning-based image quality assessment methods to adversarial attacks. Finally, Alban Marie (IETR-INSA Rennes, France) delivered a talk on the exploration of lossy image coding trade-off between rate, machine perception and quality.

5G Key Performance Indicators (5GKPI)

The 5GKPI group studies relationship between key performance indicators of new 5G networks and QoE of video services on top of them. At the meeting, Pablo Pérez (Nokia XR Lab, Spain) led an open discussion on the future activities of the group towards 6G, including a brief presentation of QoS/QoE management in 3GPP and presenting potential opportunities to influence QoE in 6G.

The 146th MPEG meeting was held in Rennes, France from 22-26 April 2024, and the official press release can be found here. It comprises the following highlights:

• AI-based Point Cloud Coding*: Call for proposals focusing on AI-driven point cloud encoding for applications such as immersive experiences and autonomous driving.
• Object Wave Compression*: Call for interest in object wave compression for enhancing computer holography transmission.
• Open Font Format: Committee Draft of the fifth edition, overcoming previous limitations like the 64K glyph encoding constraint.
• Scene Description: Ratified second edition, integrating immersive media objects and extending support for various data types.
• MPEG Immersive Video (MIV): New features in the second edition, enhancing the compression of immersive video content.
• Video Coding Standards: New editions of AVC, HEVC, and Video CICP, incorporating additional SEI messages and extended multiview profiles.
• Machine-Optimized Video Compression*: Advancement in optimizing video encoders for machine analysis.
• MPEG-I Immersive Audio*: Reached Committee Draft stage, supporting high-quality, real-time interactive audio rendering for VR/AR/MR.
• Video-based Dynamic Mesh Coding (V-DMC)*: Committee Draft status for efficiently storing and transmitting dynamic 3D content.
• LiDAR Coding*: Enhanced efficiency and responsiveness in LiDAR data processing with the new standard reaching Committee Draft status.

* … covered in this column.

AI-based Point Cloud Coding

MPEG issued a Call for Proposals (CfP) on AI-based point cloud coding technologies as a result from ongoing explorations regarding use cases, requirements, and the capabilities of AI-driven point cloud encoding, particularly for dynamic point clouds.

With recent significant progress in AI-based point cloud compression technologies, MPEG is keen on studying and adopting AI methodologies. MPEG is specifically looking for learning-based codecs capable of handling a broad spectrum of dynamic point clouds, which are crucial for applications ranging from immersive experiences to autonomous driving and navigation. As the field evolves rapidly, MPEG expects to receive multiple innovative proposals. These may include a unified codec, capable of addressing multiple types of point clouds, or specialized codecs tailored to meet specific requirements, contingent upon demonstrating clear advantages. MPEG has therefore publicly called for submissions of AI-based point cloud codecs, aimed at deepening the understanding of the various options available and their respective impacts. Submissions that meet the requirements outlined in the call will be invited to provide source code for further analysis, potentially laying the groundwork for a new standard in AI-based point cloud coding. MPEG welcomes all relevant contributions and looks forward to evaluating the responses.

Research aspects: In-depth analysis of algorithms, techniques, and methodologies, including a comparative study of various AI-driven point cloud compression techniques to identify the most effective approaches. Other aspects include creating or improving learning-based codecs that can handle dynamic point clouds as well as metrics for evaluating the performance of these codecs in terms of compression efficiency, reconstruction quality, computational complexity, and scalability. Finally, the assessment of how improved point cloud compression can enhance user experiences would be worthwhile to consider here also.

Object Wave Compression

A Call for Interest (CfI) in object wave compression has been issued by MPEG. Computer holography, a 3D display technology, utilizes a digital fringe pattern called a computer-generated hologram (CGH) to reconstruct 3D images from input 3D models. Holographic near-eye displays (HNEDs) reduce the need for extensive pixel counts due to their wearable design, positioning the display near the eye. This positions HNEDs as frontrunners for the early commercialization of computer holography, with significant research underway for product development. Innovative approaches facilitate the transmission of object wave data, crucial for CGH calculations, over networks. Object wave transmission offers several advantages, including independent treatment from playback device optics, lower computational complexity, and compatibility with video coding technology. These advancements open doors for diverse applications, ranging from entertainment experiences to real- time two-way spatial transmissions, revolutionizing fields such as remote surgery and virtual collaboration. As MPEG explores object wave compression for computer holography transmission, a Call for Interest seeks contributions to address market needs in this field.

Research aspects: Apart from compression efficiency, lower computation complexity, and compatibility with video coding technology, there is a range of research aspects, including the design, implementation, and evaluation of coding algorithms within the scope of this CfI. The QoE of computer-generated holograms (CGHs) together with holographic near-eye displays (HNEDs) is yet another dimension to be explored.

Machine-Optimized Video Compression

MPEG started working on a technical report regarding to the “Optimization of Encoders and Receiving Systems for Machine Analysis of Coded Video Content”. In recent years, the efficacy of machine learning-based algorithms in video content analysis has steadily improved. However, an encoder designed for human consumption does not always produce compressed video conducive to effective machine analysis. This challenge lies not in the compression standard but in optimizing the encoder or receiving system. The forthcoming technical report addresses this gap by showcasing technologies and methods that optimize encoders or receiving systems to enhance machine analysis performance.

Research aspects: Video (and audio) coding for machines has been recently addressed by MPEG Video and Audio working groups, respectively. MPEG Joint Video Experts Team with ITU-T SG16, also known as JVET, joined this space with a technical report, but research aspects remain unchanged, i.e., coding efficiency, metrics, and quality aspects for machine analysis of compressed/coded video content.

MPEG-I Immersive Audio

MPEG Audio Coding is entering the “immersive space” with MPEG-I immersive audio and its corresponding reference software. The MPEG-I immersive audio standard sets a new benchmark for compact and lifelike audio representation in virtual and physical spaces, catering to Virtual, Augmented, and Mixed Reality (VR/AR/MR) applications. By enabling high-quality, real-time interactive rendering of audio content with six degrees of freedom (6DoF), users can experience immersion, freely exploring 3D environments while enjoying dynamic audio. Designed in accordance with MPEG’s rigorous standards, MPEG-I immersive audio ensures efficient distribution across bandwidth-constrained networks without compromising on quality. Unlike proprietary frameworks, this standard prioritizes interoperability, stability, and versatility, supporting both streaming and downloadable content while seamlessly integrating with MPEG-H 3D audio compression. MPEG-I’s comprehensive modeling of real-world acoustic effects, including sound source properties and environmental characteristics, guarantees an authentic auditory experience. Moreover, its efficient rendering algorithms balance computational complexity with accuracy, empowering users to finely tune scene characteristics for desired outcomes.

Research aspects: Evaluating QoE of MPEG-I immersive audio-enabled environments as well as the efficient audio distribution across bandwidth-constrained networks without compromising on audio quality are two important research aspects to be addressed by the research community.

Video-based Dynamic Mesh Coding (V-DMC)

Video-based Dynamic Mesh Compression (V-DMC) represents a significant advancement in 3D content compression, catering to the ever-increasing complexity of dynamic meshes used across various applications, including real-time communications, storage, free-viewpoint video, augmented reality (AR), and virtual reality (VR). The standard addresses the challenges associated with dynamic meshes that exhibit time-varying connectivity and attribute maps, which were not sufficiently supported by previous standards. Video-based Dynamic Mesh Compression promises to revolutionize how dynamic 3D content is stored and transmitted, allowing more efficient and realistic interactions with 3D content globally.

Research aspects: V-DMC aims to allow “more efficient and realistic interactions with 3D content”, which are subject to research, i.e., compression efficiency vs. QoE in constrained networked environments.

Low Latency, Low Complexity LiDAR Coding

Low Latency, Low Complexity LiDAR Coding underscores MPEG’s commitment to advancing coding technologies required by modern LiDAR applications across diverse sectors. The new standard addresses critical needs in the processing and compression of LiDAR-acquired point clouds, which are integral to applications ranging from automated driving to smart city management. It provides an optimized solution for scenarios requiring high efficiency in both compression and real-time delivery, responding to the increasingly complex demands of LiDAR data handling. LiDAR technology has become essential for various applications that require detailed environmental scanning, from autonomous vehicles navigating roads to robots mapping indoor spaces. The Low Latency, Low Complexity LiDAR Coding standard will facilitate a new level of efficiency and responsiveness in LiDAR data processing, which is critical for the real-time decision-making capabilities needed in these applications. This standard builds on comprehensive analysis and industry feedback to address specific challenges such as noise reduction, temporal data redundancy, and the need for region-based quality of compression. The standard also emphasizes the importance of low latency coding to support real-time applications, essential for operational safety and efficiency in dynamic environments.

Research aspects: This standard effectively tackles the challenge of balancing high compression efficiency with real-time capabilities, addressing these often conflicting goals. Researchers may carefully consider these aspects and make meaningful contributions.

The 147th MPEG meeting will be held in Sapporo, Japan, from July 15-19, 2024. Click here for more information about MPEG meetings and their developments.

JPEG Trust reaches Draft International Standard stage

The 102nd JPEG meeting was held in San Francisco, California, USA, from 22 to 26 January 2024. At this meeting, JPEG Trust became a Draft International Standard. Moreover, the responses to the Call for Proposals of JPEG NFT were received and analysed. As a consequence, relevant steps were taken towards the definition of standardized tools for certification of the provenance and authenticity of media content in a time where tools for effective media manipulation should be made available to the general public. The 102nd JPEG meeting was finalised with the JPEG Emerging Technologies Workshop, at Tencent, Palo Alto on 27 January.

The following sections summarize the main highlights of the 102nd JPEG meeting:

• JPEG Trust reaches Draft International Standard stage;
• JPEG AI improves the Verification Model;
• JPEG Pleno Learning-based Point Cloud coding releases the Committee Draft;
• JPEG Pleno Light Field continues development of Quality assessment tools;
• AIC starts working on Objective Quality Assessment models for Near Visually Lossless coding;
• JPEG XE prepares Common Test Conditions;
• JPEG DNA evaluates its Verification Model;
• JPEG XS 3rd edition parts are ready for publication as International standards;
• JPEG XL investigate HDR compression performance.

JPEG Trust

At its 102nd meeting the JPEG Committee produced the DIS (Draft International Standard) of JPEG Trust Part 1 “Core Foundation” (21617-1). It is expected that the standard will be published as an International Standard during the Summer of 2024. This rapid standardization schedule has been necessary because of the speed at which fake media and misinformation are proliferating especially with respect to Generative AI.

The JPEG Trust Core Foundation specifies a comprehensive framework for individuals, organizations, and governing institutions interested in establishing an environment of trust for the media that they use, and for supporting trust in the media they share online. This framework addresses aspects of provenance, authenticity, integrity, copyright, and identification of assets and stakeholders. To complement Part 1, a proposed new Part 2 “Trust Profiles Catalogue” has been established. This new Part will specify a catalogue of Trust Profiles, targeting common usage scenarios.

During the meeting, the committee also evaluated responses received to the JPEG NFT Final Call for Proposals (CfP). Certain portions of the submissions will be incorporated in the JPEG Trust suite of standards to improve interoperability with respect to media tokenization. As a first step, the committee will focus on standardization of declarations of authorship and ownership.

Finally, the Use Cases and Requirements document for JPEG Trust was updated to incorporate additional requirements in respect of composited media. This document is publicly available on the JPEG website.

A white paper describing the JPEG Trust framework is also available publicly on the JPEG website.

JPEG AI

At the 102nd JPEG meeting, the JPEG AI Verification Model was improved by integrating nearly all the contributions adopted at the 101st JPEG meeting. The major change is a multi-branch JPEG AI decoding architecture with two encoders and three decoders (6 possible compatible combinations) that have been jointly trained, which allows the coverage of encoder and decoder complexity-efficiency tradeoffs. The entropy decoding and latent prediction portion is common for all possible combinations and thus differences reside at the analysis/synthesis networks. Moreover, the number of models has been reduced to 4, both 4:4:4 and 4:2:0 coding is supported, and JPEG AI can now achieve better rate-distortion performance in some relevant use cases. A new training dataset has also been adopted with difficult/high-contrast/versatile images to reduce the number of artifacts and to achieve better generalization and color reproducibility for a wide range of situations. Other enhancements have also been adopted, namely feature clipping for decoding artifacts reduction, improved variable bit-rate training strategy and post-synthesis transform filtering speedups.

The resulting performance and complexity characterization show compression efficiency (BD-rate) gains of 12.5% to 27.9% over the VVC Intra anchor, for relevant encoder and decoder configurations with a wide range of complexity-efficiency tradeoffs (7 to 216 kMAC/px at the decoder side). For the CPU platform, the decoder complexity is 1.6x/3.1x times higher compared to VVC Intra (reference implementation) for the simplest/base operating point. At the 102nd meeting, 12 core experiments were established to further continue work related to different topics, namely about the JPEG AI high-level syntax, progressive decoding, training dataset, hierarchical dependent tiling, spatial random access, to mention the most relevant. Finally, two demonstrations were shown where JPEG AI decoder implementations were run on two smartphone devices, Huawei Mate50 Pro and iPhone14 Pro.

JPEG Pleno Learning-based Point Cloud coding

The 102nd JPEG meeting marked an important milestone for JPEG Pleno Point Cloud with the release of its Committee Draft (CD) for ISO/IEC 21794-Part 6 “Learning-based point cloud coding” (21794-6). Part 6 of the JPEG Pleno framework brings an innovative Learning-based Point Cloud Coding technology adding value to existing Parts focused on Light field and Holography coding. It is expected that a Draft International Standard (DIS) of Part 6 will be approved at the 104th JPEG meeting in July 2024 and the International Standard to be published during 2025. The 102nd meeting also marked the release of version 4 of the JPEG Pleno Point Cloud Verification Model updated to be robust to different hardware and software operating environments.

JPEG Pleno Light Field

The JPEG Committee has recently published a light field coding standard, and JPEG Pleno is constantly exploring novel light field coding architectures. The JPEG Committee is also preparing standardization activities – among others – in the domains of objective and subjective quality assessment for light fields, improved light field coding modes, and learning-based light field coding.

As the JPEG Committee seeks continuous improvement of its use case and requirements specifications, it organized a Light Field Industry Workshop. The presentations and video recording of the workshop that took place on November 22nd, 2023 are available on the JPEG website.

JPEG AIC

During the 102nd JPEG meeting, work on Image Quality Assessment continued with a focus on JPEG AIC-3, targeting standardizing a subjective visual quality assessment methodology for images in the range from high to nearly visually lossless qualities. The activity is currently investigating three different subjective image quality assessment methodologies.

The JPEG Committee also launched the activities on Part 4 of the standard (AIC-4), by initiating work on the Draft Call for Proposals on Objective Image Quality Assessment. The Final Call for Proposals on Objective Image Quality Assessment is planned to be released in July 2024, while the submission of the proposals is planned for October 2024.

JPEG XE

The JPEG Committee continued its activity on JPEG XE and event-based vision. This activity revolves around a new and emerging image modality created by event-based visual sensors. JPEG XE is about the creation and development of a standard to represent events in an efficient way allowing interoperability between sensing, storage, and processing, targeting machine vision and other relevant applications. The JPEG Committee is preparing a Common Test Conditions document that provides the means to perform an evaluation of candidate technology for the efficient coding of event sequences. The Common Test Conditions provide a definition of a reference format, a dataset, a set of key performance metrics and an evaluation methodology. In addition, the committee is preparing a Draft Call for Proposals on lossless coding, with the intent to make it public in April of 2024. Standardization will first start with lossless coding of event sequences as this seems to have the higher application urgency in industry. However, the committee acknowledges that lossy coding of event sequences is also a valuable feature, which will be addressed at a later stage. The public Ad-hoc Group on Event-based Vision was reestablished to continue the work towards the next 103rd JPEG meeting in April of 2024. To stay informed about the activities please join the event based imaging Ad-hoc Group mailing list.

JPEG DNA

During the 102nd JPEG meeting, the JPEG DNA Verification Model description and software were approved along with continued efforts to evaluate its rate-distortion characteristics. Notably, during the 102nd meeting, a subjective quality assessment was carried out by expert viewing using a new approach under development in the framework of AIC-3. The robustness of the Verification Model to errors generated in a biochemical process was also analysed using a simple noise simulator. After meticulous analysis of the results, it was decided to create a number of core experiments to improve the Verification Model rate-distortion performance and the robustness to the errors by adding an error correction technique to the latter. In parallel, efforts are underway to improve the rate-distortion performance of the JPEG DNA Verification Model by exploring learning-based coding solutions. In addition, further efforts are defined to improve the noise simulator so as to allow assessment of the resilience to noise in the Verification Model in more realistic conditions, laying the groundwork for a JPEG DNA robust to insertion, deletion and substitution errors.

JPEG XS

The JPEG Committee is happy to announce that the core parts of JPEG XS 3rd edition are ready for publication as International standards. The Final Draft International Standard for Part 1 of the standard – Core coding tools – was created at the last meeting in November 2023, and is scheduled for publication. DIS ballot results for Part 2 – Profiles and buffer models – and Part 3 – Transport and container formats – of the standard came back, allowing the JPEG Committee to produce and deliver the proposed IS texts to ISO. This means that Part 2 and Part 3 3rd edition are also scheduled for publication.

At this meeting, the JPEG Committee continued the work on Part 4 – Conformance testing, to provide the necessary test streams of the 3rd edition for potential implementors. A Committee Draft for Part 4 was issued. With Parts 1, 2, and 3 now ready, and Part 4 ongoing, the JPEG Committee initiated the 3rd edition of Part 5 – Reference software. A first Working Draft was prepared and work on the reference software will start.

Finally, experimental results were presented on how to use JPEG XS over 5G mobile networks for the transmission of low-latency and high quality 4K/8K 360 degree views with mobile devices. This use case was added at the previous JPEG meeting. It is expected that the new use case can already be covered by the 3rd edition, meaning that no further updates to the standard would be necessary. However, investigations and experimentation on this subject continue.

JPEG XL

The second edition of JPEG XL Part 3 (Conformance testing) has proceeded to the DIS stage. Work on a hardware implementation continues. Experiments are planned to investigate HDR compression performance of JPEG XL.

“In its efforts to provide standardized solutions to ascertain authenticity and provenance of the visual information, the JPEG Committee has released the Draft international Standard of the JPEG Trust. JPEG Trust will bring trustworthiness back to imaging with specifications under the governance of the entire International community and stakeholders as opposed to a small number of companies or countries.” said Prof. Touradj Ebrahimi, the Convenor of the JPEG Committee.

JPEG Trust reaches Committee Draft stage at the 101^st JPEG meeting

The 101^st JPEG meeting was held online, from the 30th of October to the 3rd of November 2023. At this meeting, JPEG Trust became a Committee Draft. In addition, JPEG analyzed the responses to its Calls for Proposals for JPEG DNA.

The 101^st JPEG meeting had the following highlights:

• JPEG Trust reaches Committee Draft;
• JPEG AI request its re-establishment;
• JPEG Pleno Learning-based Point Cloud coding establishes a new Verification Model;
• JPEG Pleno organizes a Light Field Industry Workshop;
• JPEG AIC-3 continues the evaluation of contributions;
• JPEG XE produces a first draft of the Common Test Conditions;
• JPEG DNA analyses the responses to the Call for Proposals;
• JPEG XS proceeds with the development of the 3rd edition;
• JPEG XL proceeds with the development of the 2nd edition.

The following sections summarize the main highlights of the 101^st JPEG meeting.

JPEG Trust

The 101^st meeting marked an important milestone for JPEG Trust project with its Committee Draft (CD) for Part 1 “Core Foundation” (21617-1) of the standard approved for consultation. It is expected that a Draft International Standard (DIS) of the Core Foundation will be approved at the 102^nd JPEG meeting in January 2024, which will be another important milestone. This rapid schedule is necessitated by the speed at which fake media and misinformation are proliferating especially in respect of generative AI.

Aligned with JPEG Trust, the NFT Call for Proposals (CfP) has yielded two expressions of interest to date, and submission of proposals is still open till the 15th of January 2024.

Additionally, the Use Cases and Requirements document for JPEG Fake Media (the JPEG Fake Media exploration preceded the initiation of the JPEG Trust international standard) was updated to reflect the change to JPEG Trust as well as incorporate additional use cases that have arisen since the previous JPEG meeting, namely in respect of composited images. This document is publicly available on the JPEG website.

JPEG AI

At the 101^st meeting, the JPEG Committee issued a request for re-establishing the JPEG AI (6048-1) project, along with a Committee Draft (CD) of its version 1. A new JPEG AI timeline has also been approved and is now publicly available, where a Draft International Standard (DIS) of the Core Coding Engine of JPEG AI version 1 is foreseen at the 103^rd JPEG meeting (April 2024), a rather important milestone for JPEG AI. The JPEG Committee also established that JPEG AI version 2 will address requirements not yet fulfilled (especially regarding machine consumption tasks) but also significant improvements on requirements already addressed in version 1, e.g. compression efficiency. JPEG AI version 2 will issue the final Call for Proposals in January 2025 and the presentation and evaluation of JPEG AI version 2 proposals will occur in July 2025. During 2023, the JPEG AI Verification Model (VM) has evolved from a complex system (800kMAC/pxl) to two acceptable complexity-efficiency operation points, providing 11% compression efficiency gains at 20 kMAC/pxl and 25% compression efficiency gains at 200 kMAC/pxl. The decoder for the lower-end operating point has now been implemented on mobile devices and demonstrated during the 100^th and 101^st JPEG meetings. A presentation with the JPEG AI architecture, networks, and tools is now publicly available. To avoid project delays in the future, the promising input contributions from the 101^st meeting will be combined in JPEG AI Core Experiment 6.1 (CE6.1) to study interaction and resolve potential issues during the next meeting cycle. After this integration, a model will be trained and cross-checked to be approved for release (JPEG AI VM5 release candidate) along with the study DIS text. Among promising technologies included in CE6.1 are high quality and variable rate improvements, with a smaller number of models (from 5 to 4), a multi-branch decoder that allows up to three reconstructions with different levels of quality from the same latent representation, but with synthesis transform networks with different complexity along with several post-filter and arithmetic coder simplifications.

JPEG Pleno Learning-based Point Cloud coding

The JPEG Pleno Learning-based Point Cloud coding activity progressed at the 101^st meeting with a major investigation into point cloud quality metrics. The JPEG Committee decided to continue this investigation into point cloud quality metrics as well as explore possible advancements to the VM in the areas of parameter tuning and support for residual lossless coding. The JPEG Committee is targeting a release of the Committee Draft of Part 6 of the JPEG Pleno standard relating to Learning-based point cloud coding at the 102^nd JPEG meeting in San Francisco, USA in January 2024.

JPEG Pleno Light Field

The JPEG Committee has been creating several standards to provision the dynamic demands of the market, with its royalty-free patent licensing commitments. A light field coding standard has recently been developed, and JPEG Pleno is constantly exploring novel light field coding architectures.

The JPEG Committee is also preparing standardization activities – among others – in the domains of objective and subjective quality assessment for light fields, improved light field coding modes, and learning-based light field coding.

A Light Field Industry Workshop takes place on November 22^nd, 2023, aiming at providing a forum for industrial actors to exchange information on their needs and expectations with respect to standardization activities in this domain.

JPEG AIC

During the 101^st JPEG meeting, the AIC activity continued its efforts on the evaluation of the contributions received in April 2023 in response to the Call for Contributions on Subjective Image Quality Assessment. Notably, the activity is currently investigating three different subjective image quality assessment methodologies. The results of the newly established Core Experiments will be considered during the design of the AIC-3 standard, which has been carried out in a collaborative way since its beginning.

The AIC activity also initiated the discussion on Part 4 of the standard on Objective Image Quality Metrics (AIC-4) by refining the Use Cases and Requirements document. During the 102^nd JPEG meeting in January 2024, the activity is planning to work on the Draft Call for Proposals on Objective Image  

JPEG XE

The JPEG Committee continued its activity on Event-based Vision. This activity revolves around a new and emerging image modality created by event-based visual sensors. JPEG XE aims at the creation and development of a standard to represent events in an efficient way allowing interoperability between sensing, storage, and processing, targeting machine vision and other relevant applications. For better dissemination and raising external interest, a workshop around Event-based Vision was organized and took place on Oct 24^th, 2023. The workshop triggered the attention of various stakeholders in the field of Event-based Vision, who will start contributing to JPEG XE. The workshop proceedings will be made available on jpeg.org. In addition, the JPEG Committee created a minor revision for the Use cases and Requirements as v1.0, adding an extra use case on scientific and engineering measurements. Finally, a first draft of the Common Test Conditions for JPEG XE was produced, along with the first Exploration Experiments to start practical experiments in the coming 3-month period until the next JPEG meeting. The public Ad-hoc Group on Event-based Vision was re-established to continue the work towards the next 102^nd JPEG meeting in January of 2024. To stay informed about the activities please join the Event-based Vision Ad-hoc Group mailing list.

JPEG DNA

As a result of the Call for Proposals issued by the JPEG Committee for contributions to JPEG DNA standard, 5 proposals were submitted under three distinct codecs by three organizations. Two codecs were submitted to both coding and transcoding categories, and one was submitted to the coding category only. All proposals showed improved compression efficiency when compared to three selected anchors by the JPEG Committee. After a rigorous analysis of the proposals and their cross checking by independent parties, it was decided to create a first Verification Model (VM) based on V-DNA, the best performing proposal. In addition, a number of core experiments were designed to improve the JPEG DNA VM with elements from other proposals submitted by quantifying their added value when integrated in the VM.

JPEG XS

The JPEG Committee continued its work on JPEG XS 3^rd edition. The primary goal of the 3^rd edition is to deliver the same image quality as the 2^nd edition, but with half of the required bandwidth. The Final Draft International Standard for Part 1 of the standard — Core coding tools — was produced at this meeting. With this FDIS version, all technical features are now fixed and completed. Part 2 — Profiles and buffer models — and Part 3 — Transport and container formats — of the standard are still in DIS ballot, and ballot results will only be known by the end of January 2024. The JPEG Committee is now working on Part 4 — Conformance testing, to provide the necessary test streams of the 3^rd edition for potential implementors. A first Working Draft for Part 4 was issued. Completion of the JPEG XS 3^rd edition is scheduled for April 2024 (Parts 1, 2, and 3) and Parts 4 and 5 will follow shortly after that. Finally, the new Use cases and Requirements for JPEG XS document was created containing a new use case to use JPEG XS for transport of 4K/8K video over 5G mobile networks. It is expected that the new use case can already be covered by the 3rd edition, meaning that no further updates to the standard would be needed. However, more investigations and experimentations will be conducted on this subject.

JPEG XL

The second editions of JPEG XL Part 1 (Core coding system) and Part 2 (File format) have proceeded to the FDIS stage, and the second edition of JPEG XL Part 3 (Conformance testing) has proceeded to the CD stage. These second editions provide clarifications, corrections and editorial improvements that will facilitate independent implementations. At the same time, the development of hardware implementation solutions continues.

Final Quote

“The release of the first Committee Draft of JPEG Trust is a strong signal that the JPEG Committee is reacting with a timely response to demands for solutions that inform users when digital media assets are created or modified, in particular through Generative AI, hence contributing to bringing back trust into media-centric ecosystems.” said Prof. Touradj Ebrahimi, the Convenor of the JPEG Committee.

The 145th MPEG meeting was held online from 22-26 January 2024, and the official press release can be found here. It comprises the following highlights:

• Latest Edition of the High Efficiency Image Format Standard Unveils Cutting-Edge Features for Enhanced Image Decoding and Annotation
• MPEG Systems finalizes Standards supporting Interoperability Testing
• MPEG finalizes the Third Edition of MPEG-D Dynamic Range Control
• MPEG finalizes the Second Edition of MPEG-4 Audio Conformance
• MPEG Genomic Coding extended to support Transport and File Format for Genomic Annotations
• MPEG White Paper: Neural Network Coding (NNC) – Efficient Storage and Inference of Neural Networks for Multimedia Applications

This column will focus on the High Efficiency Image Format (HEIF) and interoperability testing. As usual, a brief update on MPEG-DASH et al. will be provided.

High Efficiency Image Format (HEIF)

The High Efficiency Image Format (HEIF) is a widely adopted standard in the imaging industry that continues to grow in popularity. At the 145th MPEG meeting, MPEG Systems (WG 3) ratified its third edition, which introduces exciting new features, such as progressive decoding capabilities that enhance image quality through a sequential, single-decoder instance process. With this enhancement, users can decode bitstreams in successive steps, with each phase delivering perceptible improvements in image quality compared to the preceding step. Additionally, the new edition introduces a sophisticated data structure that describes the spatial configuration of the camera and outlines the unique characteristics responsible for generating the image content. The update also includes innovative tools for annotating specific areas in diverse shapes, adding a layer of creativity and customization to image content manipulation. These annotation features cater to the diverse needs of users across various industries.

Research aspects: Progressive coding has been a part of modern image coding formats for some time now. However, the inclusion of supplementary metadata provides an opportunity to explore new use cases that can benefit both user experience (UX) and quality of experience (QoE) in academic settings.

Interoperability Testing

MPEG standards typically comprise format definitions (or specifications) to enable interoperability among products and services from different vendors. Interestingly, MPEG goes beyond these format specifications and provides reference software and conformance bitstreams, allowing conformance testing.

At the 145^th MPEG meeting, MPEG Systems (WG 3) finalized two standards comprising conformance and reference software by promoting it to the Final Draft International Standard (FDIS), the final stage of standards development. The finalized standards, ISO/IEC 23090-24 and ISO/IEC 23090-25, showcase the pinnacle of conformance and reference software for scene description and visual volumetric video-based coding data, respectively.

ISO/IEC 23090-24 focuses on conformance and reference software for scene description, providing a comprehensive reference implementation and bitstream tailored for conformance testing related to ISO/IEC 23090-14, scene description. This standard opens new avenues for advancements in scene depiction technologies, setting a new standard for conformance and software reference in this domain.

Similarly, ISO/IEC 23090-25 targets conformance and reference software for the carriage of visual volumetric video-based coding data. With a dedicated reference implementation and bitstream, this standard is poised to elevate the conformance testing standards for ISO/IEC 23090-10, the carriage of visual volumetric video-based coding data. The introduction of this standard is expected to have a transformative impact on the visualization of volumetric video data.

At the same 145^th MPEG meeting, MPEG Audio Coding (WG6) celebrated the completion of the second edition of ISO/IEC 14496-26, audio conformance, elevating it to the Final Draft International Standard (FDIS) stage. This significant update incorporates seven corrigenda and five amendments into the initial edition, originally published in 2010.

ISO/IEC 14496-26 serves as a pivotal standard, providing a framework for designing tests to ensure the compliance of compressed data and decoders with the requirements outlined in ISO/IEC 14496-3 (MPEG-4 Audio). The second edition reflects an evolution of the original, addressing key updates and enhancements through diligent amendments and corrigenda. This latest edition, now at the FDIS stage, marks a notable stride in MPEG Audio Coding’s commitment to refining audio conformance standards and ensuring the seamless integration of compressed data within the MPEG-4 Audio framework.

These standards will be made freely accessible for download on the official ISO website, ensuring widespread availability for industry professionals, researchers, and enthusiasts alike.

Research aspects: Reference software and conformance bitstreams often serve as the basis for further research (and development) activities and, thus, are highly appreciated. For example, reference software of video coding formats (e.g., HM for HEVC, VM for VVC) can be used as a baseline when improving coding efficiency or other aspects of the coding format.

MPEG-DASH Updates

The current status of MPEG-DASH is shown in the figure below.

The following most notable aspects have been discussed at the 145th MPEG meeting and adopted into ISO/IEC 23009-1, which will eventually become the 6th edition of the MPEG-DASH standard:

• It is now possible to pass CMCD parameters sid and cid via the MPD URL.
• Segment duration patterns can be signaled using SegmentTimeline.
• Definition of a background mode of operation, which allows a DASH player to receive MPD updates and listen to events without possibly decrypting or rendering any media.

Additionally, the technologies under consideration (TuC) document has been updated with means to signal maximum segment rate, extend copyright license signaling, and improve haptics signaling in DASH. Finally, REAP is progressing towards FDIS but not yet there and most details will be discussed in the upcoming AhG period.

The 146th MPEG meeting will be held in Rennes, France, from April 22-26, 2024. Click here for more information about MPEG meetings and their developments.

The 144th MPEG meeting was held in Hannover, Germany! For those interested, the press release is available with all the details. It’s great to see progress being made in person (cf. also the group pictures below). The main outcome of this meeting is as follows:

• MPEG issues Call for Learning-Based Video Codecs for Study of Quality Assessment
• MPEG evaluates Call for Proposals on Feature Compression for Video Coding for Machines
• MPEG progresses ISOBMFF-related Standards for the Carriage of Network Abstraction Layer Video Data
• MPEG enhances the Support of Energy-Efficient Media Consumption
• MPEG ratifies the Support of Temporal Scalability for Geometry-based Point Cloud Compression
• MPEG reaches the First Milestone for the Interchange of 3D Graphics Formats
• MPEG announces Completion of Coding of Genomic Annotations

We have modified the press release to cater to the readers of ACM SIGMM Records and highlighted research on video technologies. This edition of the MPEG column focuses on MPEG Systems-related standards and visual quality assessment. As usual, the column will end with an update on MPEG-DASH.

Visual Quality Assessment

MPEG does not create standards in the visual quality assessment domain. However, it conducts visual quality assessments for its standards during various stages of the standardization process. For instance, it evaluates responses to call for proposals, conducts verification tests of its final standards, and so on. MPEG Visual Quality Assessment (AG 5) issued an open call to study quality assessment for learning-based video codecs. AG 5 has been conducting subjective quality evaluations for coded video content and studying their correlation with objective quality metrics. Most of these studies have focused on the High Efficiency Video Coding (HEVC) and Versatile Video Coding (VVC) standards. To facilitate the study of visual quality, MPEG maintains the Compressed Video for the study of Quality Metrics (CVQM) dataset.

With the recent advancements in learning-based video compression algorithms, MPEG is now studying compression using these codecs. It is expected that reconstructed videos compressed using learning-based codecs will have different types of distortion compared to those induced by traditional block-based motion-compensated video coding designs. To gain a deeper understanding of these distortions and their impact on visual quality, MPEG has issued a public call related to learning-based video codecs. MPEG is open to inputs in response to the call and will invite responses that meet the call’s requirements to submit compressed bitstreams for further study of their subjective quality and potential inclusion into the CVQM dataset.

Considering the rapid advancements in the development of learning-based video compression algorithms, MPEG will keep this call open and anticipates future updates to the call.

Interested parties are kindly requested to contact the MPEG AG 5 Convenor Mathias Wien (wien@lfb.rwth- aachen.de) and submit responses for review at the 145th MPEG meeting in January 2024. Further details are given in the call, issued as AG 5 document N 104 and available from the mpeg.org website.

Research aspects: Learning-based data compression (e.g., for image, audio, video content) is a hot research topic. Research on this topic relies on datasets offering a set of common test sequences, sometimes also common test conditions, that are publicly available and allow for comparison across different schemes. MPEG’s Compressed Video for the study of Quality Metrics (CVQM) dataset is such a dataset, available here, and ready to be used also by researchers and scientists outside of MPEG. The call mentioned above is open for everyone inside/outside of MPEG and allows researchers to participate in international standards efforts (note: to attend meetings, one must become a delegate of a national body).

MPEG Systems-related Standards

At the 144th MPEG meeting, MPEG Systems (WG 3) produced three news-worthy items as follows:

• Progression of ISOBMFF-related standards for the carriage of Network Abstraction Layer (NAL) video data.
• Enhancement of the support of energy-efficient media consumption.
• Support of temporal scalability for geometry-based Point Cloud Compression (PPC).

ISO/IEC 14496-15, a part of the family of ISOBMFF-related standards, defines the carriage of Network Abstract Layer (NAL) unit structured video data such as Advanced Video Coding (AVC), High Efficiency Video Coding (HEVC), Versatile Video Coding (VVC), Essential Video Coding (EVC), and Low Complexity Enhancement Video Coding (LCEVC). This standard has been further improved with the approval of the Final Draft Amendment (FDAM), which adds support for enhanced features such as Picture-in-Picture (PiP) use cases enabled by VVC.

In addition to the improvements made to ISO/IEC 14496-15, separately developed amendments have been consolidated in the 7th edition of the standard. This edition has been promoted to Final Draft International Standard (FDIS), marking the final milestone of the formal standard development.

Another important standard in development is the 2nd edition of ISO/IEC14496-32 (file format reference software and conformance). This standard, currently at the Committee Draft (CD) stage of development, is planned to be completed and reach the status of Final Draft International Standard (FDIS) by the beginning of 2025. This standard will be essential for industry professionals who require a reliable and standardized method of verifying the conformance of their implementation.

MPEG Systems (WG 3) also promoted ISO/IEC 23001-11 (energy-efficient media consumption (green metadata)) Amendment 1 to Final Draft Amendment (FDAM). This amendment introduces energy-efficient media consumption (green metadata) for Essential Video Coding (EVC) and defines metadata that enables a reduction in decoder power consumption. At the same time, ISO/IEC 23001-11 Amendment 2 has been promoted to the Committee Draft Amendment (CDAM) stage of development. This amendment introduces a novel way to carry metadata about display power reduction encoded as a video elementary stream interleaved with the video it describes. The amendment is expected to be completed and reach the status of Final Draft Amendment (FDAM) by the beginning of 2025.

Finally, MPEG Systems (WG 3) promoted ISO/IEC 23090-18 (carriage of geometry-based point cloud compression data) Amendment 1 to Final Draft Amendment (FDAM). This amendment enables the compression of a single elementary stream of point cloud data using ISO/IEC 23090-9 (geometry-based point cloud compression) and storing it in more than one track of ISO Base Media File Format (ISOBMFF)-based files. This enables support for applications that require multiple frame rates within a single file and introduces a track grouping mechanism to indicate multiple tracks carrying a specific temporal layer of a single elementary stream separately.

Research aspects: MPEG Systems usually provides standards on top of existing compression standards, enabling efficient storage and delivery of media data (among others). Researchers may use these standards (including reference software and conformance bitstreams) to conduct research in the general area of multimedia systems (cf. ACM MMSys) or, specifically on green multimedia systems (cf. ACM GMSys).

MPEG-DASH Updates

The current status of MPEG-DASH is shown in the figure below with only minor updates compared to the last meeting.

In particular, the 6th edition of MPEG-DASH is scheduled for 2024 but may not include all amendments under development. An overview of existing amendments can be found in the column from the last meeting. Current amendments have been (slightly) updated and progressed toward completion in the upcoming meetings. The signaling of haptics in DASH has been discussed and accepted for inclusion in the Technologies under Consideration (TuC) document. The TuC document comprises candidate technologies for possible future amendments to the MPEG-DASH standard and is publicly available here.

Research aspects: MPEG-DASH has been heavily researched in the multimedia systems, quality, and communications research communities. Adding haptics to MPEG-DASH would provide another dimension worth considering within research, including, but not limited to, performance aspects and Quality of Experience (QoE).

The 145th MPEG meeting will be online from January 22-26, 2024. Click here for more information about MPEG meetings and their developments.